All Tech Considered
12:47 pm
Mon October 28, 2013

What You Need To Know About Babies, Toddlers And Screen Time

Originally published on Tue October 29, 2013 12:15 pm

This week, we're exploring the tech frontier through the eyes of our children. So we're starting with the littlest ones — babies. Can certain kinds of screen time help babies learn?

To find some answers, I employed the help of my 1-year-old daughter, Eva. She's still a wobbly walker and the sum total of her speaking skills sound like gibberish. But she has no problem activating Siri, the virtual assistant on my iPhone. Her 16-month-old friend, Lily, is even savvier with the gadgets.

"She knows how to turn the iPad on, she knows how to slide her finger across," says her mom, Kim Trainor.

That gets to the technology tension in modern parenting: You want your kids to be technologically adept — but without giving them so much screen time that it's not healthy for development.

"If I think about my childhood, a lot of these things didn't exist. And obviously my parents didn't have to think about what the exposure might do to us," Trainor says. The tech frontier for our kids is changing so fast that the guidelines are barely keeping up with it.

Case in point: Just two years ago, when San Francisco-based nonprofit Common Sense Media surveyed families with children 8 and under, just 8 percent owned tablets like iPads. That's now jumped five-fold — to 40 percent. And the percent of children with access to some sort of smartphones and tablets has jumped from half of those surveyed to 75 percent. (Read the full report.)

Pediatricians discourage passive screen time for children 2 and under.

Baby Lily's mom says she follows her pediatrician's guideline to discourage screen time until after her daughter turns 2. But the doctor behind the American Academy of Pediatrics 2011 policy guideline discouraging screen time for kids under 2 says it specifically concerns passive screen viewing. That is, plopping the baby in front of a TV or film, or having media on in the background.

"The concern for risk is that some kids who watch a lot of media actually have poor language skills, so there's a deficit in their language development. We also have concerns about other developmental issues because they're basically missing out on other developmentally appropriate activities," says Dr. Ari Brown, the lead author on the American Academy of Pediatrics policy statement discouraging screen time for babies under 2.

On Monday, the pediatrics group released updated media guidelines for children and adolescents. While still discouraging screen time for children under 2, the policy recommends a balanced approach to media in the homes instead of blanket bans. We've laid out some of the latest thinking on screen time for babies and toddlers, below.

There's a key difference between passive screen time and active screen time.

Research indicates that activities like Skyping or FaceTime — in which the baby communicates with a live human on the screen — can actually help babies learn.

"[Lily] watched her little message from her dad who had bought her a ball and said, 'This is a ball.' " Trainor says that when Lily called her father on Skype a few days later, she associated him with the ball. "She went 'ball, ball, ball,' " Trainor says.

Vanderbilt University developmental psychologist Georgene Troseth conducts some of the country's leading research on children and screens. She says Skyping isn't like watching TV because it's a social interaction.

"We're finding pretty consistently — in fact, two recent studies with actual Skype [calls] — that children do seem to learn better when there is social interaction from a person on video. So it's kind of encouraging with FaceTime or Skype for parents and grandparents to know that [with] that interaction, the children might actually be willing to learn from a person on a screen because of the social interaction showing them what's on the screen is connected to their lives," Troseth says.

The research on touch-screen apps is unclear. Apps and games labeled "educational" may not necessarily help your child learn.

Touch-screens are taking over and babies seem especially great at working with them. Lily, the 16-month-old, showed me how she shuffles through photos on her mom's phone.

Parents, meanwhile, keep hearing about "educational" apps. Troseth says be wary, for now.

"There's nothing wrong with a toy being fun, engaging a child for an amount of time. But to promote it as being educational we really need to do research to find out, is having it be interacting, doing anything to make it easier to learn from?" she asks.

Aim for a balanced approach — for you and your baby.

Since the research on touch-screens isn't clear yet, Brown offers some advice in the meantime.

"We still have questions. If you're planning on using interactive media with your child, use it with your child, sit down with your child and engage with them because that's going to be more valuable than anything," Brown says.

It's valuable time with her 14-month-old daughter that taught another mom — Jennifer Grover — about her own relationship with screens.

"It's just amazing how good they are at mimicking what they see. So I've definitely had to learn to kind of rein in my attention to the laptop, or my attention to my phone in front of her, because whatever I'm doing that's what she wants to be doing," Grover says.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

So, let's hear now from Elise Hu.

ELISE HU, BYLINE: Meet my one-year-old baby Eva. She's still a wobbly walker and the sum total of her talking skills sound something like this.

EVA STILES: (Unintelligible)

HU: But she has no problem activating Siri...

(SOUNDBITE OF TONES)

HU: ...the virtual assistant on my iPhone.

STILES: (Unintelligible)

SIRI: I don't know what you mean by rock.

STILES: (Unintelligible)

HU: When we meet up at the park with Eva's friend Lily, who is 16 months, it's clear Lily is even savvier with the gadgets. Her mom, Kim Trainor explains.

KIM TRAINOR: She knows how to turn the iPad on. She knows, you know, how to slide her finger across.

HU: Which gets to the technology tension in modern parenting: You want your kids to be technologically adept but without giving them so much screen time that it's not healthy for development. Again, Lily's mom, Kim Trainor.

TRAINOR: If I think about my childhood, a lot of these things didn't exist. And obviously my parents didn't have to think about what the exposure might do to us.

HU: Did you read up on studies? Is that how you knew not to expose the babies?

TRAINOR: My pediatrician had been forthright in telling me things like, you know, it's probably practical not to give them too much exposure when they're under two.

HU: So to figure out what's behind the avoid-screens-before-two policy, I called up one pediatrician who would know.

DR. ARI BROWN: I'm Dr. Ari Brown.

HU: She was the lead author on the American Academy of Pediatrics 2011 policy statement that discouraged passive media use for children under age two. Dr. Brown says sitting around watching TV or movies is the worst kind of screen time for babies.

BROWN: The concern for risk is that some kids who watch a lot of media actually have poor language skills, so there's a deficit in their language development. We also have concerns about other developmental issues because they're basically missing out on other developmentally appropriate activities.

HU: So no plopping down babies to sit passively before screens - got it. But what if the subjects on screen interact with the babies?

(SOUNDBITE OF BABIES GIGLING)

HU: Like what happens when you Skype?

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: Hello? Hey, Eva.

HU: Eva seems to really enjoy Skyping with her grandparents. And Lily is learning from it, as her mom explains.

TRAINOR: She watched her little message from her dad who had bought her a ball and said, you know, this is a ball. And as soon as she realized we were trying to leave a message for dad, she went: Ball, ball, ball.

HU: It turns out some Skyping benefits are now backed up by research. Vanderbilt University Developmental Psychologist Georgene Troseth conducts some of the country's leading research on children and screens. Troseth says Skyping isn't like watching TV, because it's a social interaction.

GEORGENE TROSETH: We're finding pretty consistently that, in fact, two recent studies with actual Skype, you know, that children do seem to learn better when there is social interaction from a person on video. So it's kind of encouraging with face time on Skype for parents and grandparents to know that that interaction, the children might actually be willing to learn from a person on a screen because of the social interaction, showing them that what's on the screen is connected to their lives.

HU: That kind of research has now guided the American Academy of Pediatrics to update its policy guidelines, recommending that families set media use diets in their own homes and be balanced about screen time. Because not only is there a difference between TV time and Skyping, but babies are also interacting in another way, using touch screens, and they're doing it really well.

Lily showed me how she shuffles through photos on her mom's iPhone.

LILY TRAINOR: Turtle.

TRAINOR: That is a turtle.

(LAUGHTER)

HU: And parents keep hearing about quote, "educational" apps. The developmental psychologist, Troseth, says be wary, for now.

TROSETH: There's nothing wrong with a, you know, a toy being fun, engaging a child for an amount of time. But to promote it as being educational, and we really need to do research to find out, is having it be interactive doing anything making it easier to learn from.

HU: Since the research on touch screens isn't clear yet, Dr. Brown offers some advice in the meantime.

BROWN: We still have questions. If you're planning on using interactive media with your child, use it with your child. Sit down with your child and engage with them because that is going to be more valuable than anything.

HU: It's valuable time with her 14-month-old daughter that taught another fellow mom, Jennifer Grover, about her own relationship with screens.

JENNIFER GROVER: It's just amazing how good they are at mimicking what they see. So I've definitely had to learn to kind of rein in my attention to the laptop, or my attention to my phone in front of her, because whatever I'm doing that's what she wants to be doing.

HU: In the interest of helping our tiny humans learn, we adults are learning a lot. As babies bravely explore their new, screen-filled worlds, so do we.

TRAINOR: Bye-bye.

HU: Elise Hu, NPR News.

CORNISH: Tomorrow morning, a report on video games and children, the tension it can create with parents and how game developers design them to be irresistible.

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #1: Mind Craft.

(SOUNDBITE OF GUNFIRE)

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #2: I have an iPad mini and I've totally loaded it up with games, Tiny Tower, Scribble Market, Battle of Nations, Puzzle Craft...

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: A lot of the games are set up so that you can't just stop. If you stop, you lose points or you lose money or you lose something.

CORNISH: That's tomorrow on MORNING EDITION. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.